An Early “Lens” Into Predicting JR Outcomes by Country of Citizenship

Recently, I received a data set from IRCC which tracks the total numbers and outcomes of litigations in the Federal Court. This is important, because the Federal Court itself has indicated that it does track these statistics as their system are unable to do so. From the Bar side, there is nobody tracking – so really, IRCC is the only source of this data.

This data is likely also a key input their decision-making systems and litigation strategy.

We have this data from January 2018 to June 2023. I have shared some of the preliminary analysis (thank you Excel “Analyze Data” tool) on both Linkedin and Twitter.

In this post, we will look at the three countries leading the litigation volume (India, Nigeria, and Iran) and take a look at the respective outcomes for citizens of each respective country.

Before, we begin, it is important to look at total numbers:

So ironically, whether a decision gets leave is a 50/50 decision. However, that does not capture the other outcomes such as withdraws at leave. In practice we’ve always thrown around this 20% of cases are actually allowed, which is actually supported by the stats!

Further breaking down the stats to three file types – Visa Officer Refusals versus RPD and RAD judicial reviews, we also see some differences:

I think what is surprising is that Visa Officer decisions have such a high discontinued – consent at leave rate. I believe this will be the target of a lot of policy discussion moving forward, but I will save this discuss for another blog.

Country of Citizenship Discrepancies

But let’s move now to the three different countries and look at discrepancies as well as the file types as this can help give us more insight:

Let’s start with India. The main thing that sticks out with India is the Allowed rate is much lower than for other countries, with higher percentages of both withdraws and consents.

With India, removal order cases are the most common at 26.86% followed by RAD Decisions at 19.65% and Visa Officer Refusals at 17.67%.

Now, is the interesting one – Iran.

Iran’s consent at leave rate is extremely high (45.76%), leave dismissal rate much lower (24.73%) than average.

This makes a bit more sense once we look at file types for Iran:

Visa Officer Refusals and Mandamus cases makea up a huge nearly 43% of all cases – and these ones are likely more amenable to consent before leave.

Now let’s take a look at our final example, Nigeria:

Nigeria has a much higher than average dismissal at leave rate and much lower Consent at Leave Rate.

When we look at the file types, we can futher insight into this:

RAD/Removals/and RPD matters make up 60% of all cases and these are ones that are more likely contentious. However, I cannot eliminate other factors that may make up the higher refusal rate and certainly a critical analysis should be performed. I do not think we collectively still understand how things such as name or country identifiers on a file can influence decision-making, although I understand bias training does occur at various Tribunal and Court levels.

Preliminary Data Only

This data obviously is just a selection and will need much more analysis. Some of the classification categories are not clear and will require clarification.

I do hope to share the full document shortly, but I am doing consultations with data analysts, academic scholars, the Federal Court, and stakeholders to make sure we treat it the right way. In my ideal world, this data is made transparent and can be used to help train and audit decision-making for bias. However, the flipside of future decisions reinforcing the discrepancies in the name of consistency is real. There are major policy implications arising from the release and study of data such as this.

About Us

Heron Law Offices is located in the quaint and culturally vibrant neighbourhood of Mountainview. We can be found in the heart of Burnaby, minutes away from the Patterson Skytrain Station in a comfortable and flexibled shared corporate office.

We have capacity and technology to assist clients all over Canada and the world utilizing secure cloud-based solutions.

CONTACT US

We're here to help you

Fill out the form below or email me at info@vancouverimmigrationblog.com

    Translate »